Once opened, Coconut Cult 8 oz and 16 oz jars are best enjoyed within 2–3 weeks when kept refrigerated. After 3 weeks, we can no longer guarantee product quality and do not recommend consuming the jar.
Before opening, the timeline works a little differently. And because Coconut Cult continues fermenting in the jar, your last spoonful might not taste or look exactly like your first.
Here’s what to know.
Before You Crack the Seal
If your jar is unopened and properly refrigerated, it’s good through the Sell By Date printed on the label.
We don’t recommend consuming an unopened jar past that date. Once you open it, though, a new timeline begins.
Once It’s Open
For our 8 oz and 16 oz jars, we recommend enjoying Coconut Cult within 2–3 weeks after opening for peak freshness and product quality.
After three weeks, we don’t recommend continuing to consume the jar.
And yes — even if you crack it open right on the Sell By Date, you still have that 2–3 week opened-jar window.
No need to finish 16 ounces in one heroic sitting.Â
What If I Open It on the Sell By Date?
This one gets its own section because it can be confusing.
The Sell By Date applies to an unopened jar.
Once you open it, follow the opened-jar guidance instead.
So if your Sell By Date is November 15 and you open the jar on November 15, you still have approximately 2–3 weeks from the day you opened it.
Why Does My Jar Get Tangier?
Because your jar is still doing its thing.
Coconut Cult is fermented, and that fermentation continues in the jar. As it gets closer to its Sell By Date, you may notice its flavor becoming more tangy or sour and its texture becoming thicker or airier.
You may also notice:
- bubbles
- a fluffy or airy texture
- a thicker spoonful
- natural effervescence
- a stronger fermented tang
A jar early in its life and one closer to its Sell By Date can have a noticeably different personality.
Same Cult, different mood, all cultured goodness. 🙏Â
Does Coconut Cult Need to Stay Refrigerated?
Yes. At all times.
Coconut Cult is a perishable refrigerated product, so we recommend keeping your jar cold from the time you get it home through the last spoonful.
Don’t leave an opened jar sitting on the counter between servings. If Coconut Cult reaches warm or room temperatures, it can increase the risk of spoilage.
Our very complicated storage ritual:
Open. Spoon. Close. Fridge.
That’s it.
What If My Jar Looks Different Than the Last One?
Some variation is expected with an actively fermented product. One jar may be a little thicker. Another may feel lighter or more airy.
One may have more bubbles.
Another might bring a little extra tang.
Those differences can happen naturally throughout fermentation and as the product moves closer to its Sell By Date.
If something about your specific jar has you concerned, though, don’t guess.
Worried About Your Jar?
Reach out to our Customer Experience team. Send us a photo along with any details you have about the jar, and we can take a closer look with you.
Fermented products can have a lot of personality. We’d rather check out your specific jar than have you trying to play detective in front of the refrigerator. 🔍Â
The Cultie Cheat Sheet
For 8 oz and 16 oz Coconut Cult jars:
Unopened: Keep refrigerated and enjoy through the Sell By Date.
Opened: Enjoy within 2–3 weeks.
Opened on the Sell By Date: You still have the normal 2–3 week opened-jar window.
Open longer than 3 weeks: We do not recommend consuming it.
Storage: Keep refrigerated at all times.
Getting tangier, thicker, airier, bubbly, or more effervescent? Your jar continues fermenting, so its flavor and texture can evolve over time.